The Spin Doctor Europadisc's Weekly Column

The Power of Myth

  8th December 2021

8th December 2021


The interest aroused by our recent review of Scenes from the Kalevala on the BIS label serves as a powerful reminder of the enduring appeal that myths and legends have for composers. Although every indication is that music had been a part of myth-telling since ancient times, it was only in the early 17th century with the representational magic of the early operas of Peri, Caccini, and above all Monteverdi’s L’Orfeo (1607) that the musico-dramatic potential of classical myths was unleashed with full force. The particular attraction of the story of Orpheus for musicians is self-evident: to regain his beloved Eurydice from the depths of Hades, he wins over the subterranean deities with the extraordinary power of his singing and playing. That he loses her again by looking back as he leads her out of the Underworld only adds poignancy to the story, although many adaptations (like that set by Gluck in 1762, more than a century-and-a-half after the Orpheus craze first took root) involve a further twist by reuniting the pair with a deus ex machina. (Such divine intervention became de rigeur during the heyday of opera.)

Composers from Rossi and Sartorio to Malipiero and Glass have continued the Orphic obesession over the centuries (even Haydn got in on the act with his 1791 opera L’anima del filosofo, originally intended for performance in London). But the wider preoccupation of composers (and by no means only operatic ones) forms a rich seam through music history from the dawn of the Baroque to the present day. The Baroque remains a highpoint, partly because the prolific symbolism and well-known archetypes that characterise classical myth and legend made possible the presentation of ideas and emotions that would have been thought de trop (and in some cases even dangerous) if presented in contemporary guise. And the presentation of a stage action in which the classical deities reigned supreme over the lives of mere mortals was customarily taken as a direct nod to divinely-appointed monarchs and their lowlier subjects.

Any history of music which left out mythologically-inspired works would be a slender one indeed: for starters, most of the operas of Lully and Rameau would be gone, as would Purcell’s Dido and Aeneas and King Arthur, most of Handel’s operas, several of Mozart’s (including Idomeneo), but also Beethoven’s music for The Creatures of Prometheus (Beethoven being one of the most Promethean of composers!), Berlioz’s Les Troyens and Offenbach’s comic masterpieces Orpheus in the Underworld.

As Enlightenment values blossomed into human-centred rationalism, the trend in operas was to a more human-centred focus, a shift of emphasis evident in Mozart’s late operas (particularly the politically-charged Beaumarchais comedy Le nozze di Figaro, but also in the symbol-laden, quasi-mythological Die Zauberflöte), an even in the treatment of such legends as that of Medea in Cherubini’s famous setting (1797). Beethoven’s only opera, the openly political Fidelio, represents for many the apex of this trend, but the focus on human history and even contemporary realism was one that dominated Italian opera in particular (the Romantic histories of Donizetti, Bellini and Verdi, and the verismo school of Puccini, Mascagni and Leoncavallo).

Yet as the Romantic century progressed, myth and legend were put to powerful use in the search for national identities. The most obvious example is Richard Wagner’s use of medieval sources in his music dramas, above all his transformation of the Middle High German Nibelungenlied (the so-called ‘German Iliad’) into his vast tetralogy Der Ring des Nibelungen. Such artistic appropriation of national epics was by no means limited to Germany. In the Czech lands, Smetana’s Libuše (1881) is a magnificent operatic setting of the myth of Queen Libuše, who prophesied the founding of Prague, while his cycle of symphonic poems Má vlast (‘My Homeland’, 1874-79) drew on a variety of legends from Czech myth, including that of the fierce warrior maiden Šárka, whose story was also set in operas by Fibich (1897) and Janáček (1887, first performed in 1925). By contrast, Dvořák’s most notable contributions are surely his four late symphonic poems of 1896 after the folk ballads of Karel Jaromír Erben (right down to their motifs, which are based on the rhythms of Erben’s texts).

Further East, the rich heritage of Russian folk legend was eagerly taken up by Rimksy-Korsakov in his operas, from the Ostrovsky-based Snow Maiden (1882) to the fabulously scored epic The Legend of the Invisible City of Kitezh and the Maiden Fevroniya (1907). Rimsky’s legacy is plainly evident in Stravinsky’s ballet The Firebird (1910), while his following two works in the genre, Petrushka (1911) and The Rite of Spring (1913) were founded respectively on the Russian traditions of magic puppetry and ‘pictures of pagan Russia’, with the latter incorporating several folk melodies into its riot-inducing score. The myth-based works of Stravinsky’s neo-classical period, by contrast, are all on classical legend (Oedpius rex, Apollon musagète, Perséphone and Orpheus), in a cool, detached style which exemplifies not only his middle and late output but also the changed attitude towards myth and its artistic and expressive possibilities in the 20th century (in which Jungian psychology and the theories of Claude Lévi-Strauss became increasingly influential).

Other examples of this shift can be found in the Expressionist and Symbolist movements in early-20th-century music, as represented above all by such quasi-legendary works as Bartók’s Bluebeard’s Castle (1911, based on a tale by Charles Perrault), and the brooding half-world of Debussy’s Pelléas et Mélisande (1902, setting Maeterlinck’s famous 1893 drama). Of Richard Strauss’s operas on classical themes, by far the most successful is Ariadne auf Naxos (1912), with its witty libretto by Hofmannsthal contrasting the high seriousness of the opera seria characters with the subversive antics of the ‘low’ comedians of the commedia dell’arte. Yet there’s also a pronounced mythic feel to what some Straussians would consider the highpoint of his Hofmannsthal collaborations in Die Frau ohne Schatten (1919), with its complex, heavily symbolic, magic fairy-tale libretto and sumptuous, vocally demanding score. Sibelius’s many orchestral and vocal works inspired by Finnish myth (including the Kalevala) in the years leading up to Finnish independence in 1917 are well documented, and perhaps most striking because they are so different in tone from such predecessors as Liszt, Smetana and Dvořák.

The subsequent use of myth and legend from the mid-20th century onwards is too varied to deal with in such a limited space as this, but mention should be made of a composer of our own time who, perhaps more than any other, has recognised not merely the expressive and theatrical but also the structural potential of myth and legend. Since the mid-1960s Harrison Birtwistle has produced an astonishing output of works based not just on classical myth – including The Mask of Orpheus (1986), Panic (1995) and The Minotaur (2008) – but also on folk sources as in Down by the Greenwood Side (1969) and Yan Tan Tethera (1986), popular sources as in Punch and Judy (1968), and even the ‘modern myth’ of King Kong in The Second Mrs Kong (1994) to a libretto by Russell Hoban. For anyone interested in the possibilities of combining myth and music, Birtwistle’s output is an endlessly fascinating one.

A few suggested recordings:
Monteverdi - L’Orfeo (La Venexiana/Cavina)  GCD920941
Berlioz - Les Troyens (Strasbourg PO & Chorus/Nelson)  9029576220
Smetana - Libuše (Prague National Theatre/Krombholc)  SU39822
Dvořák - Symphonic Poems (Czech PO/Mackerras)  SU40122
Rimsky-Korsakov - The Legend of the Invisible City of Kitezh (Teatro Lirico di Cagliari/Vedernikov)  866028890
Sibelius - Tone Poems (Lahti SO/Vänskä et al.)  BISCD190002
Stravinsky - Oedipus rex (Czech PO/Ančerl)  SU36742
Birtwistle - The Minotaur (ROH/Pappano)  OA1000D (DVD) / OABD7052D (Blu-ray)

Latest Posts


Of Versions and Editions

25th May 2022

Anyone whose interest in classical music is of more than the casual, ‘background listening’ kind will at some point or other have come upon the question of versions. Even with such an old warhorse as Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture (a work currently placed on the naughty step), the choice of ‘with or without choir’ arises, while other perennial crowd-pleasers such as ‘Albinoni’s Adagio’ (actually a concoction by 20th-century musicologist Remo Giazotto) and Allegri’s Miserere open up several cans of worms. You might be asked, if... read more

read more

When is a symphony not a symphony? (A Question of Genre)

18th May 2022

These days, genre looms large in the music world. It’s an affliction that looms large in the world of popular music, with various new types of pop and rock music emerging on an almost annual basis. In classical music, the situation appears to be more stable, at least on first appearances. The venerable Gramophone magazine has for many years divided its reviews into orchestral, chamber, instrumental (just one player), vocal (anything sung that isn’t opera) and opera, with a separate section for ‘Jazz & World Music’. Other... read more

read more

Works in Focus: Janáček’s ‘Jenůfa’

12th May 2022

Few music lovers today would disagree with the assertion that Leoš Janáček made some of the most distinctive and individual contributions to the operatic repertoire of the 20th century. His greatest operas, most of them comfortably under two hours in length, pack a powerful emotional punch out of all proportion to their compact dimensions, characterised by a pithy musical language that thrives on bold sonorities and contrasts, and a vocal style that is deeply rooted in the rhythms and shapes of the Czech language. Yet... read more

read more

Huffing and puffing...

3rd May 2022

Around this time each year, the British classical music-loving public (such as it is) takes part in a time-honoured sport: huffing and puffing about the newly-revealed programme for the summer’s BBC Proms season. This year, following two summers in which the concerts were severely curtailed thanks to the global Covid pandemic, the announcement was keenly awaited, and the scrutiny has been particularly intense.
The director of the BBC Proms, David Pickard, has an unenviable task in choosing a multi-themed programme for the... read more

read more

Aspects of Romantic opera

27th April 2022

Perhaps the most public manifestation of musical Romanticism was in the opera houses of Europe, from the many courtly and municipal opera houses of Germany and Italy to the grand theatres of France and Russia. Ever since opera had developed from a court occasion for a select, aristocratic elite to an entertainment for the wider public, the draw of its combination of music, drama and scenic spectacle had been immense – akin to the advent of movies and then television in the 20th century. And its capacity to tackle a huge... read more

read more
View Full Archive