The Spin Doctor Europadisc's Weekly Column

Who is the Greatest of Them All?

  29th November 2023

29th November 2023

It was probably in 1999 that I became aware of the scale of the problem and the sheer stupidity of it all: HMV stores (remember those?) and the UK’s Channel 4 network teamed up (together with minor input from Classic FM) to conduct a poll to determine the ‘Music of the Millennium’. Well, it was asking for trouble, wasn’t it? A millennium: that’s a thousand years by normal reckoning. Yet with the sole exception of the ‘Best Piece of Classical Music’* and ‘Best Classical Composer’** categories, the entire poll was dominated by music of the previous four decades. In a millennial context, the choices looked desperately myopic. Best Songwriter (of the Millennium, remember): John Lennon; of Franz Schubert and Robert Schumann, not a whiff, let alone Guillaume de Machaut or Josquin Desprez. Best Male Singer? Elvis Presley, followed by Robbie Williams and Michael Jackson. Sorry about that, Pavarotti, Caruso, Martinelli, Senesino, et al.

Unfortunately, things are hardly less moronic when it comes to ‘classical’ music alone. Classic FM’s annual ‘Hall of Fame’ seems to be an ongoing ‘Old Firm’ tussle between Rachmaninov’s Piano Concerto no.2 and Vaughan Williams’s The Lark Ascending. Still, at least it doesn’t claim that these are the best classical music there is, let alone of the last thousand years. But there are plenty of other forms of indulging in the rather schoolboyish practice of ranking: Radio 3’s ‘Building a Library’, for instance, or the top choice in Gramophone magazine’s ‘Gramophone Collection’, both of which take an individual piece of music and whittle the choices down to the eventual winner. (We hold our hands up here: our own ‘Top Ten’ Discs of the Year are a similar exercise in telling you The Recordings You Really Need To Own.)

The problem with this sort of musical beauty parade is even more apparent with online forums where, for instance, one contributor recently declared a still-living pianist (unquestionably a great artist in her own right) as ‘the greatest Bach player ever’. While several respondents were quick to offer their own alternatives, depressingly few pointed out that the greatest Bach player ever might perhaps have been Bach himself… Recent swooning reviews of Ravel’s Daphnis et Chloé and Bach’s Goldberg Variations have fallen into a similar trap. People can get very defensive of their own particular favourites, but it’s the blind certainty of those who claim a particular singer, player, orchestra or conductor as The Greatest that is most worrying. Music shouldn’t be a competition. The fact that one work, performance or performer means a lot to me doesn’t mean that everyone should agree. Enthusiasm can be a powerful tool in persuading others to open their minds, but simply declaring (as many classical presenters seem to do these days) that something is ‘amazing’ is no substitute for nuanced description. In other words: don’t tell me, show me.

The practice of ranking recordings – whether by sales or by (often superficial) comparison with others (faster than Toscanini, slower than Klemperer) – risks reducing the joys of listening to music to a sort of glorified Crufts. Some artists seem to achieve top-ranking partly because of the sheer number of their recordings (Karajan’s recordings for DG and EMI flooded the market in the 1960s to 1980s, exaggerating their merits through sheer commercial pulling power), others because of their very scarcity (Carlos Kleiber being an obvious example). Sage heads warn over the hype surrounding the latest Wunderkinds, harking instead back to the glory days of Furtwängler, Klemperer, Solomon and Backhaus; yet their long-departed seniors would no doubt have held a similar position and looked back still further with longing to Weingartner, Nikisch, Schnabel and Cortot. By all accounts, Gustav Mahler was one of the most remarkable conductors ever to mount the podium, yet you rarely encounter him in discussions of the ‘greatest’ conductors because of the lack of recordings. In music – as the ‘Music of the Millennium’ poll amply demonstrated – memories can be shockingly short, yet at the same time the recent past can cast a long shadow over artists of the present day. Some figures are forgotten almost as soon as they exit the stage, while for others death seems to cement their legendary status.

All of which simply adds to the bafflement of potential newcomers to the world of classical music. For all the ‘iconic’ status of certain works, composers and performers, there’s no telling what may grip the listener at any given moment. The proliferation of unknown repertoire of the past being uncovered by such labels as CPO, MDG and Toccata Classics, to name just three of the more enterprising labels out there, suggests that there’s certainly an audience for music that sits outside the canon. For those wanting to explore beyond the Cruftian world of the Great Works and Great Performers that seem to be the bread and butter of the commercial industry, there’s probably never been a better time to explore the cultural byways and escape the treadmill of the endless quest for ‘the Greatest’.

A few recent recommendations:
N Berg - Symphonies 4 & 5 7776652
Casali - Sacred Music from Eighteenth-Century Rome TOCC0429
Kalinnikov - Orchestral Works MDG95222406
Müller-Hartmann - Chamber Works CHAN20294
Pepusch - Chandos Anthems ACC24397

* Rather predictably, Vivaldi’s ‘Four Seasons’
** Equally predictably, Mozart (followed by Beethoven and J.S. Bach)

Latest Posts

In Praise of Theodora

21st February 2024

Surely the most intriguing of all Handel’s oratorios is his antepenultimate work in the genre. Unlike the biblical works on Old Testament subjects with which the composer had enjoyed some of his greatest successes, Theodora is based on the story of an early Christian martyr, persecuted for her beliefs by the Roman authorities during the reign of Diocletian. The story is a bleak one. For her refusal to sacrifice to the Roman gods, Theodora is first ordered to serve as a prostitute, and then – when her beloved Didymus, a Roman... read more

read more

Remembering Seiji Ozawa (1935–2024)

14th February 2024

Seiji Ozawa, who has died at the age of 88, was one of the chief representatives of a new generation of conductors who emerged on the international scene in the 1960s. Others included Claudio Abbado, Lorin Maazel, Zubin Mehta and Riccardo Muti. Replacing the largely self-taught conductors of earlier generations who had studied ‘on the job’ in junior Kapellmeister posts, many of the new cohort learned their craft on formal conducting courses, and debate continues to rage as to which is the best route for the budding maestro.... read more

read more

Classical Music: Where to Begin?

7th February 2024

Of the many questions we’re asked by our customers, one of the most difficult – posed to us just recently – is how to start a classical music collection. Where to begin? Without knowing the person, their character, likes and dislikes over a wide range of subjects from film and literature to food and clothes, it’s almost impossible to give a helpful answer. In music, there’s no ‘one size fits all’. When the old and much-revered Penguin Guide to Classical Music wrote sniffily of one slightly esoteric album that ‘it will not... read more

read more

Celebrating Luigi Nono (1924-1990)

31st January 2024

One of this year’s major musical anniversaries – the centenary of the birth of Luigi Nono on 29 January – has so far been little marked on the international scene. On the day itself, BBC Radio 3 broadcast none of his music (this week’s Composer of the Week is, instead, Stravinsky). A native of Venice, Nono was one of the leading figures of the post-war avant garde, and for many new music insiders his name ranks alongside those of Boulez and Stockhausen in the modernist Pantheon. Yet outside of his native Italy and the... read more

read more

Works in Focus: Smetana’s Má vlast

17th January 2024

Amid the seemingly constant flow of new Bruckner recordings being issued in anticipation of the composer’s 200th birthday on this September, it’s easy to overlook another important musical bicentenary that falls this year. Bedřich Smetana was born on 2 March 1824, six months and two days before his Austrian counterpart. Although he was raised in a German-speaking household and mastered the Czech language only later in life, Smetana formed the keystone in the musical Czech national revival of the 19th century. He had... read more

read more
View Full Archive