The Spin Doctor Europadisc's Weekly Column

Aspects of Romantic opera

  27th April 2022

27th April 2022


Perhaps the most public manifestation of musical Romanticism was in the opera houses of Europe, from the many courtly and municipal opera houses of Germany and Italy to the grand theatres of France and Russia. Ever since opera had developed from a court occasion for a select, aristocratic elite to an entertainment for the wider public, the draw of its combination of music, drama and scenic spectacle had been immense – akin to the advent of movies and then television in the 20th century. And its capacity to tackle a huge variety of themes, from classical myth to recent history, from the realistic to the fantastic, ensured it a wide following wherever it became established. Fashions and audience tastes changed, but those composers and librettists who could follow or - better still - anticipate and create trends were rewarded with huge public enthusiasm (however transitory) for their work.

Romantic opera had its origins in France and Germany, with Cherubini, Auber and (above all) Weber laying its foundations. But it was Gioachino Rossini who, in the 1810s and 20s, laid the development of Italian bel canto, first in northern and central Italy, then in Vienna and London, and finally in Paris where, after the success of his 1829 grand opera Guillaume Tell (based on Friedrich Schiller’s 1804 drama Wilhelm Tell), he retired from large-scale composition at the age of 37, with another four decades of life ahead of him. During his relatively brief but extraordinarily influential career as an opera composer, he wrote in the major Italian genres of the time – opera buffa and opera seria – with a particular penchant for comic opera (L’italiana in Algeri, Il barbiere di Siviglia, La Cenerentola), but also tackling such Romantic favourites as Shakespeare (Otello, 1816) and Walter Scott (La donna del lago, 1819 - just nine years after the publication of Scott’s narrative poem).

Rossini’s output, though uneven, at its best fizzes with energy and invention, but it also set the standard for Italian bel canto which was further developed by his compatriots Gaetano Donizetti and Vincenzo Bellini. The shorter-lived Bellini excelled in the serious genres of melodramma and tragedia lirica, often to libretti after French models, the high point of which is undoubtedly the classically-themed Norma (1831). Donizetti’s vast operatic output encompassed comic, tragic and historical themes, including French grand opera, among which the tragic Lucrezia Borgia (1833, after Victor Hugo) and Lucia di Lammermoor (1835, after Scott), the comic L’elisir d'amore (1832) and La Fille du regiment (1840) are highlights.

Donizetti was a significant influence on the young Verdi, whose output had an unmistakably Italian identity even when treating such a subject as Shakespeare’s Macbeth (1847) – the Bard’s oeuvre having become common international property since the Romantic revival of interest in his works. Italian opera is normally regarded as somewhat apart from mainstream Romanticism, yet Verdi’s operatic subjects – largely historical, with the famous biblical exception of Nabucco – have impeccable Romantic credentials. Even though there is a strong populist element to them (Verdi knew his audience as few other composers have), the tension between the public and the personal – a cornerstone of Romantic art – is keenly highlighted, even amid the grand display of Aida (1871) and the textually tortuous but psychologically powerful Don Carlos (1867, after Schiller).

For all Verdi’s dalliances with French grand opera, it the two great masterpieces of his old age, both to libretti by Arrigo Boito on Shakespearean models – Otello (1887) and Falstaff (1893) – that manage to transcend national boundaries and fashions and approach the urgency of through-composed music drama. Though never quite relinquishing the last faint vestiges of ‘number opera’, they have a succinctness that looks beyond the next generation of Italians in the verismo school and toward the compactness of Janáček.

The sprawling canvases of French grand opera, represented at their best (if one discounts Verdi) by Giacomo Meyerbeer’s Robert le diable (1831), Les Huguenots (1836) and Le Prophète (1849), were a significant influence on the young Richard Wagner, whose third opera Rienzi (1842) Meyerbeer did much to smooth the path for in his capacity as Prussian Court Kapellmeister. Wagner later rejected the classically-themed Rienzi and its two predecessors, as well as the influence of Meyerbeer, and immersed himself in German and Nordic myth and legend. While his Romantic operas Der fliegende Holländer (1843), Tannhäuser (1845) and Lohengrin (1850) all contain undeniable traces of ‘number opera’, in their emphatic focus on redemption through love they pave the way for his late, self-styled ‘music dramas’ which rely on an intricate web of leitmotives to prop up a highly fluid approach to traditional harmony – most notable in Tristan und Isolde (1865) and Parsifal (1882).

Wagner’s late works, with their emphasis on the individual hero as a vehicle of redemption, became the subject of increasingly suspect adulation (culminating, of course, in the 1930s and 40s), although they are anything but popular crowd-pleasers in the Italianate mould. But their musical influence, particularly on the Francophone composers who flocked to the early Bayreuth festivals, was enormous, and their anticipation of the worlds of Symbolism and Expressionism, as well as the gradual disintegration of the certainties of traditional tonality, place them as crucial transitional works (and even instigators) in the shaping of musical modernism. Wagner’s own writings cite Beethoven and Schopenhauer – key figures in the early development of Romanticism – as his major influences. How fitting (or, perhaps, ironic) that he in turn should be one of those to read its last rites…

A few recommended recordings:
Marschner - Der Vampyr  C5184
Rossini - Guillaume Tell  6407632
Bellini - Norma  OA1247D / OABD7225D
Donizetti - Lucia di Lammermoor  4783045
Verdi - Macbeth  4497322
Verdi - Don Carlos  9029581793
Meyerbeer - Les Huguenots  2564662125
Wagner - Lohengrin  2564690256
Wagner - Tristan und Isolde  E4775355

Latest Posts


Bringing Vaughan Williams to new audiences: An interview with Midori Komachi

28th June 2022

There’s no doubt that among this year’s musical anniversaries, the sesquicentenary of Ralph Vaughan Williams’s birth ranks high for many performers and audiences. The ever-popular Lark Ascending, the symphonies, orchestral fantasias, choral works and song settings will be well-represented, but among the more enterprising musicians exploring RVW’s musical legacy is violinist Midori Komachi. In partnership with experienced pianist Simon Callaghan, she is releasing an album containing all of the composer’s works for violin and... read more

read more

Of Artificial Intelligence and lost music

21st June 2022

Ever keen to keep abreast of the latest trends, we’ve been given pause for thought by two recent news items and how they might relate to the world of classical music. The first was an article on the BBC News website about the impact that Artificial Intelligence (AI) is having on the world of professional tennis. Statistical analysis in the form of data analytics from matches involving leading professional tennis players has been harnessed in a range of apps and techniques. There are also video programmes that can analyse any... read more

read more

Early Music: A Stock-Taking, Part 2

15th June 2022

In the past couple of decades, Early Music can be said to have come of age. After a shaky but extremely characterful start in the early years of the 20th century, and a postwar ‘rebirth’ with the likes of Nikolaus Leonhardt and Gustav Leonhardt spearheading exciting new ventures, the 1970s and 80s can retrospectively be likened to moody teenage years, with an insistence on authenticity and dogma that raised the hackles of the traditionalist establishment. (Talk of ‘tradition’ is always problematic vis-à-vis Early Music:... read more

read more

Early Music: A Stock-Taking

8th June 2022

Our recent piece on ‘Versions and Editions’ prompted an interesting response from some of our regular readers, as a result of which we take a closer two-part look at the history and present state of the Early Music movement in the 20th and early 21st centuries.

Increasing numbers of editions of Early Music repertoires (everything from the Baroque and before) fostered a growing interest among performers. Among the first to take a deeper interest in such repertoires were instrument player and manufacturer Arnold... read more

read more

How to Celebrate a Jubilee

31st May 2022

The music industry loves anniversaries. The centenaries, sesquicentenaries, bicentenaries (and so on) of composers’ births, deaths and other significant occasions (the 2013 centenary of Stravinsky’s Le Sacre du printemps, for example) provide excuses for new recordings, reissues and box-set compilations of varying enormity and expense. Even literary figures with musical leanings (like Proust) are celebrated with themed releases, as are other significant figures from history, including royalty. So it’s a little surprising... read more

read more
View Full Archive